INDIAN DEMOCRACY AND CASTE SYSTEM
Dr.M Anwar
Indians usually boast around as the bearers of
democratic norms and holders of civilian rule through
regular holding of elections and observing rituals
essentially required by an egalitarian state. The
arrangements appear to be going well with the hegemonic
designs of elite class or upper caste Hindus yearning to remain in
power by clever use of majority vote in India. The "Shining India" slogan jingled through media campaigns
and other costly Public Service Announcements (PSAs)
also raise speculations about the ground realities in
India where discrimination of low caste Hindus and
non-Hindu communities is the common practice.
Democracy in India has not changed the status
and destiny of untouchables and the MALLEECH. Although at
the time of election upper class Hindus make promises
with tall claims using voters as a tool to tread the
power path. The low caste majority is virtually forced to
participate in the electoral process. There are dire
consequences for those who opt to vote for a losing
candidate. Thus coercion through state authority is
openly applied to punish the political opponents and
their supporters. The process of electioneering is
repeated every time the government completes its term but
nothing changes the fate of low caste communities in
India. The question arises as to why cannot democracy
bring a change in Indian culture where people are treated
as equals with similar rights to be citizens of India,
having freedom of expression, rights to elect their own
representatives, freedom of religious practices and other
rights as envisaged in a democratic state? Does India
employ coercive methods to hide her real face as a
democratic state and cheats her own people by using them
as the instruments of power by discriminating against
them as untouchable and impervious? Indian social system
has the answer.
Unfortunately Indian social system is based on
the notion of purity and pollution in which upper class
does not interact on equal terms with the low castes.
Exchange of eatables is as prohibited among the upper and
low caste communities as the marriages. One gets polluted
by touching the untouchables, hence drinking or eating
with low castes is completely prohibited. Resultantly
social exchange activities carry subjective and double
meanings as one is never sure to expect that common
exchange of pleasantries and promises made by the stake
holders will carry the same weight. Social order in India
is hate driven and low caste communities irrespective of
their claims to be Indians by birth, are despised as much
as the outsiders are loathed and rejected. Such a
democracy practically leads people to incapacitation and
wheezing debilitation while India shines only for the
elite class.
Reportedly United Nations Human Rights Council
(UNHRC) is taking into consideration to recognize
caste-based discrimination as a human rights violation.
This will certainly annoy India where low caste
untouchable Hindus, Dalits, Muslims and Christians are
habitually mal-treated on the basis of their castes.
Nepal, where untouchability is traditionally practiced,
has openly supported UNHRC draft principles and
guidelines for effective elimination of caste based
discrimination. This is radically different from India’s
aversion to the internationalization of the caste
problem. Adding to India’s discomfiture, Sweden in its
capacity as the president of European Union (EU) has
stated that caste-based discrimination is an important
priority for EU. If the issue continues to gather
momentum, UNHRC may in a future session adopt the draft
principles and guidelines and send these for adoption to UN General Assembly.
Though India succeeded in her efforts to keep caste out
of the resolution adopted by the 2001 Durban conference
on racism, yet the issue has emerged in a different
guise. It will encourage other states to raise their
voice against discrimination based on caste inequalities,
exposing the real face of Indian democracy.
|